Wed 10 Oct 2007
Bad Medicine
Posted by Shanna under Indonesia
[11] Comments
As I mentioned in an earlier post, I read Elizabeth Gilbert’s “Eat, Pray, Love” at the beginning of our trip. For those of you who haven’t read the book, it tells of the author’s year of travels through Italy, India and Bali. Like us, she spent most of her time in Bali in the city of Ubud, where she befriended both a traditional Balinese healer named Wayan and an old medicine man named Ketut Liyer. Both Wayan and Ketut seemed to me to be of a Bali from long ago–one that I very much wanted to learn more about. I arrived in Ubud determined to track down both of them and was happy to see that Ms. Gilbert had made the task significantly easier by posting their addresses on her website.
Happily, Wayan’s shop was walking distance from our hotel. We dropped by on Saturday afternoon and, within a few minutes, we were sitting with her at her shop’s only table drinking tumeric juice with honey (“for strength,” she said). As a sort of preview of her services, she gave us a quick once-over and then listed a few of the things that ailed us. I should have been suspicious when, after looking at Derek’s fingernails, she pronounced that he needed to eat fewer sweet things (the man loves food more than anyone I know, but he’s definitely not a dessert eater), but I was breathlessly excited to have met the woman who, in the book, had cured an infection normally remedied by a week’s worth of antibiotics using only some herbal compresses. I made an appointment to meet with her for two hours on Monday. Derek, who was more skeptical, particularly when he heard the price (more than double what the other “healing shops” charged), passed.
When Monday morning came around, I arrived in Wayan’s tiny shop expecting to be amazed at her abilities and newly convinced of the healing powers of herbal remedies. When I left three and one-half hours later, I had received only a sobering illustration of the destructive powers of the popularity that came to her after the book’s publication. (I’m sure the same fate has befallen countless vendors who find themselves listed in the Lonely Planet or other guidebooks and, therefore, on most Westerners’ short list of acceptable places to frequent).
For fifteen minutes, Wayan provided me with a list of my ailments that was quite similar to the one she had given me two days before. It reminded me of a horoscope, in that it was vague enough to avoid being inaccurate (“you sometimes have a busy mind”) and general enough to apply to just about anyone (“you need to drink more water”). She supplied me with a bag full of pills, potions and powders, one of which promised to address everything from diabetes to “new and old paralyzed” to “finishing the nasty smell of mouth and nose,” as well as a schedule of when to take what. She then directed me to go upstairs.
Wayan had explained earlier that the book’s popularity had caused her business to boom and had necessitated the hiring of two assistants, a woman who looked to be about 18 and a man in his 20s. These two met me upstairs and proceeded to rub me with betel leaves, rice mixed with galangal root, aloe vera and, at one point, pieces of a cucumber. The treatments weren’t accompanied by any explanation. While I found myself wondering both whether Wayan was coming back (I’d understood my appointment to be with HER) and why someone was rubbing cucumber in my eye, the experience was not altogether unpleasant.
The assistants then directed me to lie face-down on a massage table. (What? Language barriers prevented me from pressing them for more information. I definitely had not signed up for a massage, but ok….) I did as instructed, and then things got confusing. I was left alone with the male assistant, who, in a nutshell, began acting inappropiately. (Don’t worry, Mom, nothing criminal or even very serious happened.) I left Wayan’s shop as soon as I could and hurried back to the hotel with the events of the morning replaying in my mind. Â
After reflecting more fully on the experience, I returned to Wayan’s shop a few hours later with Derek in tow and confronted Wayan about what had happened. To her credit, Wayan appeared to be both appalled and surprised at her employee’s behavior. What she said by way of an explanation gave me an important insight into both the depths of her beliefs and the corrupting powers of the fame that had come to her. According to her, the man’s actions had been caused by evil spirits born of the jealousy of other Balinese people over her good fortune. Her popularity meant that she had too many clients to handle so, when she saw me that morning, she had been too drained to provide any healing and had instead needed to relegate me to her assistants. She was sorry; she would deal with her assistant; she was so, so sorry. Both Derek and I noticed, incidentally, that she never offered to refund my money. I had come to her shop in search of an “authentic, Balinese experience” (perhaps this fact alone reveals my naivete). I left disillusioned.Â
Dear Shanna
That is shocking. I am surprised that you have taken it lightly. Thank goodness that nothing too bad came of it. This “lady” sounds like a professional con-artist who seems to employ cheap crooks and makes a living out of bamboozling tourists. Live and learn, I suppose.
Love
Rico
PS I am enjoying your blog tremendously!
I’ve told you millions of times: “hippies are worthless.” Yet you still go to some herbal medicine shop… so disappointed. Next time, before entering, think, is this going to turn out positively, or is some creepy dude gonna lock me in a room and try to give me the bad touch?
I wouldn’t feel too bad. Pretty much the same thing happened to Ponce de Leon, and he’s still my favorite conquistador.
Being forced to confront the meaning of “authenticity”–a construct indelibly linked with our own desires, hopes, and beliefs–is one of the more valuable lessons travel has afforded me. Despite my longing to find a different world in the places I’ve traveled, it seems that I always come away being reminded that we’re all part of the same world. Regardless of its trappings or manifestations, humanity seems to shares a core of driving wants and needs. There lives the authentic, which I will readily concede is more easily addressed when embued with the strength of tumeric juice and honey.
That said, if you find the fountain of youth, I wouldn’t mind a call.
I am sorry to hear about your experience. I met Wayan in July and had a wonderful session with her personally and with her 3 male assistants who did a great job. For myself she told me things about my liver, gallbader, stomache etc. that I knew about after have several tests before leaving US. She was accurate with my illness. I also agree with you on a few levels about fame/fortune and it affects Bali people. There is another amazing healer Ubud Bodyworks who is real and gifted.
I laughed when I read about how Wayan being changed with her fame and fortune, had you paid closer attention to the story of wayan you would have seen that she was already like that. Did it not tell how she tried to get more money from Liz? never the less the assistant’s massage was probably scary to say the least and for that I am sorry to hear of the experience going thatr way for you. However the rest was probably worth it as it makes a funny story and memory for you. I hope to go to Bali one day soon myself, thank-you for you blog as it helps me want to achieve visiting there more.
One thing I noticed about Wayan was that she “rescued’ the two young girls off the street only to put them to seemingly constant, supposedly unpaid work at the back of her shop. While Tutti comes home from school and sits drawing with her mother and her friends, the two Kututs seem to be always out the back preparing meals. Hopefully I have got this wrong but there is no mention of them going to school or participating in family life apart from them all sleeping together in the same bed.
This sounds a lot like child slavery to me. I’ll be happy to have my mind put at rest if anyone knows this not to be true.
Wayan the healer charges USD 80 (!!!) now for her readin g (compare the outcome with others and find out we all have the same diseases)and a 2 hour hours treatment. I visited her January 2009 and wish I read “the book” before my visit. It felt like a scam. After reading the Ubud part of the book this week I am sure she does not deserve any recommendation.
Reason for me to visit her was that I felt very tired and had no energy at all since 2 weeks. I asked her about the details of the treatment and she explained: Bring 80 USD tomorrow. In her shop were 2 Australian ladies telling me she was really good and they just had their treatment. Guess they also paid 80 USD…..
In August 2009 I paid $85 for my “treatment” with “Dr.” Wayan (as the business card she gave me states) although she did only the body reading (which was pretty much what every middle aged westerner apparently is told–nothing that wouldn’t have been easy to intuit given my age and where I was from and she did not pick up on me having had cancer) gave instructions to her assistants a few times, blew on my stomach once and threw the buckets of water on my body at the end. I assumed I’d be there for one hour and it was nearly 4 hours, I had no idea that my body was going to be “worked over” by 3-4 young men! My husband, who not so patiently waited through my treatment and the meal served to me after that, was quite upset about what he saw as a “scam” especially after watching Wayan convince a young woman to go get more money from the ATM in order to pay her because she would not be there the next day. The “many-handed massage” body scrubs and polishes was definitely a unique and unforgettable experience. Although costly by Balinese standards a 4 hour treatment including a delicious and balanced meal and a huge basket of herbal remedies, oils, etc. to take home would obviously would cost hundreds of dollars in the US. I suspect “Dr.” Wayan is skilled in her medicinal craft and has also succumbed to a bit greedy and vainity (when we asked to take a photo she had us wait a good 15 minutes while she changed out of jeans into traditional Balinese clothing and fixed her hair) or perhaps she is simply part “healer” part scam artist. I did wish later that if I could only see one of them I’d chosen to visit the other healer mentioned in the book Eat, Pray, Love, Ketut Liyer.
I lived in Ubud for 3 month this spring. I’ve been a naturopathy consultant for over 30 years with many many successes. I was shocked at how badly Wayan treated her “clients” and staff. It was a total high priced scam perpetrated against what I would can “naive Westerners.” And that house she supposedly built “for everyone” does not exist for anyone but herself. The only good thing about that day was her sweet daughter, Tutti. I read a post about about Wayan perhaps being sucked in my fame and fortune but a longtime local who assured me that Wayan was this way long before the book and film came along.
While there, I treated a few of my Balinese friends and their families with my natural remedies (with stunning success, I might add). One in particular needed follow up care and since I didn’t know any other traditional healers, I went ahead and sent her to Wayan, thinking surely she would treat own of her own. Not so. Wayan turned her away because she couldn’t pay the $80USD tourist price. Had she been able to pay it, she would have gotten in return poor, even dangerous treatments in a filthy setting full of Wayan’s negative energy.
Pass the word to beware of this one. She now has a nice house for herself, a beautiful care, lots of money, and scams perhaps dozens of people daily — one of whom had stage 4 cancer. My Balinese friend (who’s shop is across the little street) and I warned her and she was very grateful as she was on the way over to Wayan.
Ketut Liyer, on the other hand, is not so much a powerful healer, but is every bit as sweet and the actor in the film. Definitely worth a visit in my opinion. He had me clarifying things in Liz’s letter and book as his Engligh is not good. It was very sweet.
BEST OF LUCK TO YOU ALL.
Shanna, it is good to see people printing honest reviews. I am amazed Wayan acted appalled at her staffs behavious with you, as she was sexually inapporopraite with my then husband and another male friend of mine. She basically wrecked my marriage after scamming my ex out of a lot. Everyone’s comments here are quite true as we were in contact with her for a long period of time. This was well before the movie, so she was like this prior to her new found fame.. A lot of my story is very personal, but I want people to be wary of Wayan, She does know some stuff, but she uses in a very non spiritual/healing way. My ex, did a lot of running around for the house that Elizabeth paid for, but I gather Wayan planned to rent it out rather than live there, and remains at the dive she works out of in Jalan Jembaran. We had many conversations about hygeine etc, my son got typhoid fever with her, and we had a fight about placing the toilet in the kitchen at the new house, basically she didnt want to hear you opinion if it didnt suit her. And then she insulted some top architect (who agreed me me on the toilet in the kitchen) as he was giving her free advice that would have cost a fortune, only to have her go off at him also. I fell sorry that someone has to be so grasping, because I believe she serves good healthy food and could actually do very well without scamming everyone. She had another young girl when we visited and my ex paid her school fees, uniform etc. When we returned a few months later, the child was gone, we weren’t allowed to contact her, and I said to my ex that I reckon she had pulled her out of school, sent her home and collected the remaining school fees, he agreed with me.
Shanna, it is good to see people printing honest reviews. I am amazed Wayan acted appalled at her staffs behavious with you, as she was sexually inapporopraite with my then husband and another male friend of mine. She basically wrecked my marriage after scamming my ex out of a lot. Everyone’s comments here are quite true as we were in contact with her for a long period of time. This was well before the movie, so she was like this prior to her new found fame.. A lot of my story is very personal, but I want people to be wary of Wayan, She does know some stuff, but she uses in a very non spiritual/healing way. My ex, did a lot of running around for the house that Elizabeth paid for, but I gather Wayan planned to rent it out rather than live there, and remains at the dive she works out of in Jalan Jembaran. We had many conversations about hygeine etc, my son got typhoid fever with her, and we had a fight about placing the toilet in the kitchen at the new house, basically she didnt want to hear you opinion if it didnt suit her. And then she insulted some top architect (who agreed me me on the toilet in the kitchen) as he was giving her free advice that would have cost a fortune, only to have her go off at him also. I fell sorry that someone has to be so grasping, because I believe she serves good healthy food and could actually do very well without scamming everyone. She had another young girl when we visited and my ex paid her school fees, uniform etc. When we returned a few months later, the child was gone, we weren’t allowed to contact her, and I said to my ex that I reckon she had pulled her out of school, sent her home and collected the remaining school fees, he agreed with me. I believe in Karma.. so I know the universe will set things to right, but meantime, warn your friends if they go to visit to be wary..